On Tuesday morning, I popped into the bank to take out cash to buy flowers for my office. Without thinking twice, I held the door for the person behind me. Turns out it was a kid asking for money. Immediately my guard went up. I was annoyed, angry, offended. I thought, "What, because I'm a white woman in your neighborhood getting money out of an ATM you think I'm rich and have money to spare? I just want to take this $20 out and get to the train, kiddo, okay? You're not my problem." He had a school field trip that day and his dad had been out work and he didn't have enough money to get on the train that day. Or so he said. I rolled my eyes and reached into my pocketbook. "Sorry hon, this is all the change I can spare." I scooped out the pennies, dimes and nickels and practically threw them at him as I rushed out the door, some of the coins crashing to the ground.
I haven't stopped thinking about that kid since.
Living in a big city, I've heard all kinds of stories from folks trying to squeeze change out of strangers: My car ran out of gas and I just need a few dollars to get to the hospital to visit my dying mother/sister/brother; I live with my fellow homeless friends under (pick a bridge) and it's my turn to go out and scavenge for food; I'm homeless and just need a dollar or two for beer. At least that last guy was honest. But who's to say the others weren't? I've become so hardened to all the liars and scammers that I ignore everyone, even those who might actually need help. When faced with the hypothetical question, "Would you spare a dollar to help a child eat, learn, grow, or have a chance?", who wouldn't say "YES, of course!". But when faced with the actuality, I became hostile, skeptical and dismissive.
I'm ashamed of how I treated that boy. Whether or not he was scamming me, I still should have taken the opportunity to treat him with respect. Maybe instead of rushing out of the bank practically throwing the change at him, I could have placed it in hands and said, "Good luck, hon." Even if he were just scamming me maybe that extra kindness would have at least felt like a human worthy of respect instead of a vagrant scraping up coins off the dirty floor. But again, I'm supposing. I don't know what he felt.
The question of how to balance the taking care of our fellow man with the need for self-preservation is a tricky one. And I don't have an answer. I struggle with it everyday in this beautiful, heartbreaking city.